Poly Friendly Cities: Exploring Polyamory in Brooklyn

Brooklyn, New York, stands as one of the most diverse and culturally rich boroughs in the United States. Known for its vibrant neighborhoods, creative spirit, and progressive attitudes, Brooklyn has become a haven for individuals seeking community and acceptance, including those in non-traditional relationships. Whether you’re a Brooklyn local or considering a move to the area, this guide offers a look at the borough’s unique offerings for polyamorous individuals—those who embrace ethical non-monogamy as a relationship model.

In a place where inclusivity is celebrated and diversity thrives, Brooklyn’s polyamorous community is steadily growing, supported by a range of welcoming spaces, events, and resources. From its active dating scene to its array of social venues and meetups, Brooklyn offers plenty of opportunities for polyamorous people to connect, learn, and thrive. This guide will take you through everything you need to know about navigating the poly-friendly world of Brooklyn, including the best places to meet others, key resources, and essential tips on building a life that celebrates love in all its forms.

Whether you’re looking to connect with like-minded people, explore inclusive nightlife, or simply learn about the poly community in Brooklyn, this guide is here to help you feel right at home in one of New York’s most dynamic boroughs. Let’s dive into Brooklyn’s vibrant polyamorous landscape and discover what makes this city a welcoming place for love without limits.

Table of contents

Polyamory Community Overview

Brooklyn’s polyamorous community is thriving, with a supportive environment rooted in the borough’s history of progressive values, artistic energy, and a welcoming culture for alternative lifestyles. This openness is embodied by the local organizations, events, and resources that cater specifically to polyamorous individuals, often overlapping with LGBTQ+ spaces and broader non-monogamy advocacy networks.

Brooklyn has established itself as a major hub for polyamorous living in New York City, partly due to its diverse community and the work of organizations like Open Love NY, a prominent nonprofit that promotes polyamory and provides educational resources and community events throughout NYC. The group hosts regular gatherings, educational workshops, and “Poly Cocktails” mixers, which have been running successfully for over 17 years and provide safe spaces for polyamorous individuals to connect, socialize, and share experiences. These events have made Brooklyn a key spot for meeting like-minded individuals and accessing resources that support ethical non-monogamy in a social setting.

Brooklyn’s polyamory community also reflects the borough’s intersectional focus, addressing the needs of marginalized communities within the poly community, such as LGBTQ+ individuals and people of color. Many local therapists, including those on TherapyDen, specialize in polyamorous and open relationships, ensuring that mental health and counseling services are accessible and inclusive. This support extends to relationship counseling specifically designed for navigating the complexities of polyamorous family structures, including couples counseling, family dynamics, and personal growth as part of a poly lifestyle.

Brooklyn’s neighborhoods, like Williamsburg and Bushwick, are especially poly-friendly due to their well-established arts and LGBTQ+ communities, which often embrace non-monogamy as part of a broader acceptance of diverse identities. The polyamorous community here is active and visible, with members participating in art spaces, queer-friendly venues, and co-living arrangements that foster supportive environments for people in non-traditional relationships. Brooklyn continues to attract new members to the poly community who value a place where diversity, openness, and self-expression are celebrated, making it one of the most welcoming boroughs for polyamorous individuals.

Brooklyn’s polyamorous dating and social scene is vibrant, fueled by both online platforms and in-person events that foster connection among those interested in ethical non-monogamy. With the rising popularity of polyamory, several dating apps and local events cater to the polyamorous community, making it easier to meet like-minded people while embracing Brooklyn’s culture of inclusivity.

Smiling black entrepreneur watching laptop during coffee break

Online Dating Platforms

Several digital platforms have become popular tools for Brooklyn’s polyamorous individuals to connect. SwingTowns is one of the leading platforms, providing a dedicated space for polyamorous and open-minded people to meet others who value open relationships. Known for its poly-inclusive features, SwingTowns is a trusted option in the community. Other apps, such as Feeld and OkCupid, are also widely used by Brooklyn residents, offering settings specifically for non-monogamous and ethically open relationships. Feeld, in particular, has gained traction for its open approach to diverse relationship models and explicit options for polyamorous connections, making it popular among Brooklyn’s younger, progressive crowd.

Another app, Plura, focuses on building connections that honor autonomy, intersectionality, and consent, qualities embraced by many in the polyamorous community. Plura not only facilitates dating but also fosters friendships and various relationship dynamics within an environment that values respect and inclusivity. This platform’s unique approach helps people explore friendships and romantic relationships across intersecting identities, reflecting Brooklyn’s diverse and accepting culture.

In-person events remain an essential part of Brooklyn’s polyamorous social scene, allowing people to meet in comfortable and welcoming settings. Poly Cocktails, run by Open Love NY, is one of New York’s longest-running polyamory meetups, regularly hosting gatherings where polyamorous individuals can socialize in a relaxed, non-judgmental environment. The event takes place in various poly-friendly venues in Brooklyn, making it easy for attendees to connect over drinks and shared experiences in a casual setting. Similarly, Brooklyn Art Haus frequently hosts gatherings like “Poly Poly Oxen Free,” a polyamorous-themed social evening that combines theater, community activities, and networking to support connections within the poly community.

Brooklyn’s dating scene for polyamorous individuals is enriched by these events and online platforms, which collectively provide a robust support network and welcoming environment. The combination of tech-savvy dating options and accessible social gatherings makes Brooklyn an ideal place for those embracing polyamory. Whether seeking a new partner or just wanting to connect with others who share similar values, polyamorous residents have multiple avenues to build meaningful relationships within the borough.

Inclusive Venues and Spaces

Brooklyn offers a variety of inclusive venues that serve as hubs for the polyamorous community, providing safe, welcoming spaces where individuals can gather, socialize, and engage without judgment. Here’s a look at some notable poly-friendly spots across Brooklyn.

1. Brooklyn Art Haus

The Brooklyn Art Haus in Williamsburg hosts a popular event called “Poly Poly Oxen Free.” This recurring evening is designed specifically for polyamorous individuals and those curious about ethical non-monogamy, with programming that includes theater performances, community-building activities, and social networking. The event attracts a diverse crowd and fosters an inclusive atmosphere that celebrates alternative relationship structures, making it an ideal spot for polyamorous individuals looking to meet others in a relaxed, communal setting.

SOURCE: Brooklyn Art Haus

2. House of Yes

House of Yes, a vibrant venue known for its wild, inclusive parties, regularly hosts events that welcome polyamorous and LGBTQ+ individuals. This Bushwick staple is renowned for its commitment to inclusivity and its bold, immersive events that span dance parties, cabaret, and live performances. The venue’s consent-focused policies and alternative atmosphere make it a popular choice for people in non-traditional relationships. Events often center around themes of self-expression, freedom, and acceptance, aligning well with polyamorous values of open communication and inclusivity.

SOURCE: House of Yes

3. BRIC Celebrate Brooklyn! at the Lena Horne Bandshell

Each summer, BRIC hosts the Celebrate Brooklyn! festival at the Lena Horne Bandshell in Prospect Park, offering an open-air celebration that draws a large, diverse crowd. Events range from concerts to cultural performances, providing an inclusive and accessible environment for polyamorous individuals who wish to socialize in a public, friendly setting. This venue emphasizes community-building and is committed to creating spaces that celebrate diversity in all forms, making it a welcoming spot for people of various relationship structures.

SOURCE: BRIC

4. Hit Me Up NYC

Hit Me Up NYC is a curated community for polyamorous and kink-friendly individuals in New York, hosting events at multiple venues across Brooklyn. These events, including mixers and classes, often take place in inclusive locations like Three Dollar Bill, another Bushwick venue celebrated for its LGBTQ+ and alternative lifestyle-friendly atmosphere. Hit Me Up NYC emphasizes consent, safety, and community vetting, ensuring events are both enjoyable and secure, making it a highly regarded network for polyamorous individuals looking to connect within Brooklyn’s vibrant social scene.

SOURCE: Hit Me Up NYC

Brooklyn’s inclusive venues not only provide social outlets but also support the growth of the polyamorous community by fostering an environment where individuals can feel comfortable and authentic. These spots are invaluable to those practicing ethical non-monogamy, as they prioritize consent, diversity, and inclusivity, aligning with the values held by many in the polyamorous community.

Local Laws and Protections

In Brooklyn, and more broadly across New York, there are limited but growing protections for individuals in polyamorous and non-traditional relationships. Polyamory itself is legal; however, people in polyamorous relationships don’t enjoy the same legal recognition or protections as monogamous couples. Nonetheless, recent legal advancements in other cities and some developing initiatives in New York signal progress toward increased inclusivity for alternative family structures.

Recognition of Polyamorous Relationships in New York

Although New York hasn’t yet passed specific protections for polyamorous relationships, landmark court rulings show positive momentum. For example, a 2022 decision by a New York City judge set a precedent by ruling that polyamorous relationships are entitled to similar legal considerations as two-person relationships in certain cases, such as housing rights. This judgment recognizes the importance of extending tenant protections to polyamorous groups, emphasizing that non-monogamous relationships deserve legal acknowledgment and respect in New York City, including Brooklyn.

Influence of National Legal Advancements

Cities like Somerville, Cambridge, and Arlington in Massachusetts have led the way by enacting domestic partnership ordinances that recognize polyamorous relationships. These ordinances grant polyamorous partners certain rights traditionally reserved for monogamous couples, such as hospital visitation, parental rights, and city employee benefits. While these protections are not yet available in Brooklyn, the legal successes in Massachusetts have inspired advocacy groups and have fueled discussions on extending similar protections in more progressive areas, including parts of New York. Organizations like the Polyamory Legal Advocacy Coalition (PLAC) and the Chosen Family Law Center are working to advance legal recognition for polyamorous families in additional jurisdictions, including New York.

Challenges and Areas for Legal Support

Despite this progress, polyamorous individuals in Brooklyn may still face discrimination, especially in areas like housing, employment, and family law. Courts often interpret child custody and parental rights conservatively, with limited accommodations for polyamorous family structures. Polyamorous families, for instance, can face additional hurdles in legal matters related to parental responsibilities, as current laws still largely prioritize two-parent models. This can complicate custody arrangements, adoption processes, and visitation rights.

Advocacy and Future Protections

To address these gaps, legal advocates in New York encourage polyamorous individuals to secure legal protections where possible, such as through written agreements on cohabitation, parenting, and estate planning. In addition, advocacy groups like PLAC are actively campaigning to introduce local ordinances in progressive cities, aiming for broader legal recognition of polyamorous partnerships in the coming years. This advocacy not only works to extend protections but also strives to reduce the stigma against non-traditional relationships by pushing for normalization through legal channels.

For now, while Brooklyn is making strides towards inclusivity, polyamorous individuals should stay informed about their legal rights, seek legal counsel when necessary, and participate in advocacy efforts to help expand protections for polyamorous relationships and families in New York.

Resources for the Polyamorous Community in Brooklyn

Brooklyn offers a wealth of resources for the polyamorous community, from support groups to mental health professionals specializing in non-monogamous relationships. These resources help individuals navigate the unique challenges of polyamory, build community connections, and access supportive services.

1. Local Support and Advocacy Groups

Open Love NY: This New York-based organization plays a central role in advocating for polyamory and educating the public about ethical non-monogamy. Open Love NY hosts regular events like “Poly Cocktails,” offering a space for polyamorous individuals to socialize and support one another in a welcoming, open environment. The group also conducts workshops and provides educational materials to help people learn about polyamory and relationship-building practices.
Brooklyn Art Haus: Through its events like “Poly Poly Oxen Free,” Brooklyn Art Haus provides a space for people exploring polyamory to connect and engage in community-building activities, theatrical performances, and discussions about relationship dynamics in a safe and welcoming environment.

2. Mental Health Resources

Therapists Specialized in Polyamorous Relationships: Finding a therapist knowledgeable about polyamory and non-monogamy is essential for individuals who want a judgment-free space to explore relationship challenges. Platforms like TherapyDen offer directories of therapists in Brooklyn, such as Jonathan Vargas and Kirti Sinha, who specialize in polyamorous and open relationships. These professionals provide counseling that respects and understands the dynamics of non-traditional family structures, addressing issues like communication, jealousy, and emotional well-being.

3. Online Communities and Digital Resources

SwingTowns and Feeld: Both of these dating and community platforms have strong user bases in Brooklyn, offering online spaces where polyamorous individuals can connect and interact. SwingTowns, in particular, supports those exploring polyamory by emphasizing informed consent and ethical connections. Meanwhile, Feeld’s user-friendly app design caters specifically to non-traditional relationships, making it easy for people to meet potential partners and friends.

4. Educational Resources and Workshops

Loving More Nonprofit: This organization offers a range of educational materials, including webinars, workshops, and the annual Poly Living Conference. These resources cover topics such as communication in polyamorous relationships, consent, and navigating complex family structures. Loving More’s focus on education and support is invaluable for individuals seeking guidance on practicing polyamory ethically and successfully.
Polyamory Legal Advocacy Coalition (PLAC): Although focused on legal advocacy, PLAC also provides resources on understanding legal rights and protections for polyamorous families. They work to reduce stigma and advocate for the recognition of multi-partner families, which is particularly valuable for those navigating custody and parental rights.

Hit Me Up NYC: This organization curates events for the poly and kink communities in New York City, often hosted at poly-friendly venues like House of Yes and Three Dollar Bill in Brooklyn. These events, such as social mixers and educational classes, provide a supportive environment for individuals to explore non-monogamy while connecting with like-minded people.

These resources reflect Brooklyn’s commitment to inclusivity and support for alternative relationships, making it an excellent environment for those in the polyamorous community to thrive, learn, and connect. Through a combination of in-person meetups, digital platforms, and specialized support services, polyamorous individuals in Brooklyn have access to a robust network of tools and spaces designed to meet their unique needs.

Brooklyn’s polyamorous community thrives through a variety of meetups and social gatherings that foster connection, education, and support for individuals exploring ethical non-monogamy. Here are some of the key meetup groups in Brooklyn and New York City that bring the community together:

This group provides a welcoming space in Downtown Brooklyn for polyamorous people to gather and socialize in a low-key, supportive environment. Regular meetups encourage open discussions on relationship dynamics, offer a chance to build friendships, and provide a relaxed setting to exchange ideas on navigating polyamorous relationships. The group is ideal for individuals looking to connect with others in Brooklyn’s poly community without the pressure of a structured or formal setting.

2. NYC Polyamory ENM LGBTQ+ Collective

As a vibrant and inclusive group, the NYC Polyamory ENM LGBTQ+ Collective focuses on supporting the LGBTQ+ community within the realm of ethical non-monogamy. This group hosts regular events throughout Brooklyn and other parts of New York City, often including educational workshops, open discussions on relationship topics, and community-building activities. The collective’s gatherings foster a safe space for those who are both polyamorous and LGBTQ+, encouraging a respectful, non-judgmental atmosphere that prioritizes consent and inclusivity. Events vary in theme and provide opportunities to network and learn, making it especially valuable for those who experience overlapping identities within the ENM and LGBTQ+ communities.

3. The New York / New Jersey Polyamory Meetup Group

Spanning the greater NYC and NJ area, this group organizes meetups for polyamorous individuals interested in building community and sharing experiences related to ethical non-monogamy. With events held across Brooklyn, Manhattan, and nearby New Jersey locations, this group provides a regional network of support and camaraderie. Regular meetings include social mixers, educational sessions on topics like communication and relationship dynamics, and relaxed social events where members can connect over shared interests. This group is beneficial for those looking to expand their polyamorous network and engage with a larger community within the New York metropolitan area.

These meetup groups are instrumental in building a supportive polyamorous community in Brooklyn, providing resources, friendships, and a safe space for exploring diverse relationship models. By participating in these groups, members of the poly community can foster meaningful connections, learn from one another, and engage in dialogues that reduce stigma around ethical non-monogamy.

Housing and Neighborhoods

Brooklyn offers a range of poly-friendly neighborhoods that embrace inclusivity, creativity, and community, making them appealing to individuals and families in non-traditional relationships. Here’s an overview of some of Brooklyn’s most poly-friendly areas, which feature a blend of affordability, vibrant social scenes, and diverse housing options.

1. Williamsburg

Williamsburg is a prime spot for polyamorous individuals, known for its artistic vibe, lively music scene, and eclectic mix of cafes, bars, and restaurants. With a culture that celebrates diversity and self-expression, Williamsburg is home to creative and alternative communities that align well with polyamorous values. The neighborhood offers housing options from converted lofts to high-end condos, with quick access to Manhattan, making it a popular choice for young professionals and creatives alike.

SOURCE: Williamsburg

2. Bushwick

Bushwick has developed into a hotspot for the poly community, largely due to its strong art scene, affordable housing, and collaborative atmosphere. Known for its industrial aesthetic, Bushwick has transformed warehouses into spacious lofts, studios, and shared housing. The neighborhood is also home to Hacienda Villa, a sex-positive and poly-friendly co-living space designed to create a respectful and open-minded environment. Bushwick’s community is highly engaged, with frequent events and venues like House of Yes that welcome non-monogamous and LGBTQ+ individuals, making it a unique and inclusive neighborhood option.

3. Park Slope

With its family-friendly atmosphere, Park Slope appeals to those seeking a quieter, community-oriented lifestyle. The neighborhood is known for its picturesque brownstones, green spaces, and close-knit feel. Its proximity to Prospect Park and the availability of excellent schools make it ideal for polyamorous families who value both inclusivity and stability. Park Slope’s social culture is supportive and progressive, with local cafes and bookstores that often cater to diverse communities, adding to its appeal for those in alternative relationship structures.

SOURCE: Park Slope

4. Crown Heights

Crown Heights offers a culturally rich environment with a diverse population and affordable housing options. The neighborhood’s ethnic food scene and community-centered parks make it an inviting place for polyamorous individuals and families. Crown Heights is also known for its welcoming atmosphere, with various community gatherings, festivals, and art shows that bring residents together. This neighborhood is an excellent choice for those who value diversity, affordability, and accessibility within a supportive community.

SOURCE: Crown Heights

5. Fort Greene

Fort Greene is a historic neighborhood with a thriving cultural scene and numerous community-oriented spaces. Known for its tree-lined streets, 19th-century brownstones, and Fort Greene Park, it offers a peaceful residential experience while remaining close to lively social venues. Fort Greene’s inclusivity is reflected in its arts scene and progressive values, attracting a mix of artists, professionals, and polyamorous individuals who appreciate its balance of charm and cultural vibrancy.

SOURCE: Fort Greene

Each of these neighborhoods provides unique housing options and community vibes that make Brooklyn a welcoming borough for polyamorous individuals. Whether you’re drawn to the creative buzz of Bushwick, the family-friendly charm of Park Slope, or the cultural richness of Crown Heights, Brooklyn’s neighborhoods offer spaces that support diverse lifestyles and open-minded communities.

Cost of Living and Lifestyle

Living in Brooklyn can be both vibrant and costly, with the cost of living generally higher than the national average but slightly lower than Manhattan. Here’s an overview of the primary expenses to expect in Brooklyn in 2024.

Housing Costs

Housing is the largest expense in Brooklyn. The average monthly rent for a one-bedroom apartment varies by neighborhood, with rents around $2,500–$3,000 in areas like Bushwick and Bedford-Stuyvesant, while high-demand areas like Williamsburg and DUMBO can reach $4,000 or more per month. Homeownership is equally pricey, with the median single-family home price nearing $900,000 and exceeding $1.3 million in sought-after neighborhoods. Property taxes are around 0.88% annually, adding to overall housing costs.

Utilities and Internet

Monthly utility costs in Brooklyn average $175, covering basic services like electricity, heating, and water. Internet service costs around $70 per month, while mobile plans generally range from $60 to $100. These costs vary by the season, with higher heating expenses in winter.

Transportation

Brooklyn offers accessible and efficient public transportation, reducing the need for a car. A monthly unlimited MetroCard for subway and bus services is $132, making it a budget-friendly choice for commuting. Gasoline prices are about $3.50 per gallon for those who drive, though parking can be challenging and costly in denser neighborhoods.

Groceries and Dining Out

Grocery costs in Brooklyn reflect its urban setting, with prices around 15% above the national average. Monthly grocery bills range from $400 to $500, depending on dietary preferences and shopping locations. Dining out varies widely, with a casual meal at a local diner costing about $15–$20, while a three-course meal at a mid-range restaurant can set you back $80–$100. Brooklyn’s dining scene offers a diverse range of cuisines, reflecting the borough’s multicultural population.

Brooklyn’s social scene is as diverse as its residents. Entertainment options, including concerts, theater, and nightlife, offer something for everyone. Movie tickets cost around $15, and bar drinks range from $10 to $15. The borough also offers numerous free or low-cost cultural attractions, including events in Prospect Park, art galleries in Bushwick, and local farmers’ markets. For fitness enthusiasts, a gym membership ranges from $60 to $100 per month.

Healthcare and Childcare

Healthcare expenses in Brooklyn align with typical urban costs, with basic checkups around $170 and dental visits averaging $155. If uninsured, monthly premiums for private health insurance can run between $400 and $600. For families, childcare is a significant expense, with full-time private daycare averaging $2,000 per month, making it one of the more challenging costs for parents in the borough.

Brooklyn’s cost of living reflects its appeal as a cultural and residential hub, with lifestyle options that cater to diverse preferences and budgets. From affordable local markets to upscale dining and arts, Brooklyn allows residents to enjoy a vibrant, community-oriented lifestyle—albeit at a cost typical of New York City living.

Connect with Brooklyn’s Polyamorous Community Today!

Looking to build genuine connections with other polyamorous people in Brooklyn? Sign up for SwingTowns for free and discover a network of like-minded individuals in the city who value open communication, trust, and shared experiences. Whether you’re new to polyamory or a long-time participant, SwingTowns is a safe and inclusive space to find friendship, romance, and community. Join today and start connecting with others who share your relationship values!

“Swingtowns is awesome and we have no complaints. There are tremendous people and wonderful couples on here that we have had the pleasure of meeting” -wearesexy2015

Poly Friendly Cities: Exploring Polyamory in Brooklyn